jump to navigation

The contours of the 2019 elections in India January 10, 2018

Posted by prithweesh in The world this week.
Tags: , , , , , ,
add a comment

Congress probably already knew that it is going to lose the elections in Gujarat. What I really loved is the fact that they did not give up. They experimented with a variation of a “primitive” formula as a last resort.  It worked!

They tried the formula again in Mumbai and Pune recently. It seemed to have worked going by the response it got.

The formula is “Divide and Rule”.

BJP has perfected the art of dividing people as Hindus and the rest (usually Muslims) and won landslides by consolidating the votes of all the Hindus. We would always witness some riot, some controversy which would harden this dividing line between the Hindus and rest just a few months before any state election leading to BJP’s win.

Congress has now taken the battle to their gates by dividing the Hindu votes on caste lines. BJP is now nervous. It is taking on the high ground that their divide and rule is better than Congress’. We all know that both are equally bad.

I foresee that this is exactly how the 2019 elections will be fought. BJP would do well to focus on some real developmental activities during 2018-2019 which provides short term economic gains to its supporters i.e. the middle class and the small businesses. This will give them something other than right wing nationalism and religious divide to fight elections with.

I hope that one day we will have an alternative to these scheming politicians. People who will focus on the real issues which needs to be addressed to move the people of India out of the “Third World” conditions they live in. Free/Subsidised universal health care, infrastructure that is usable (Road, Public Transport, Telecom and Internet), safe drinking water, access to food which rot in the godowns of FDI and free education till the university level. I do not think these are anything extravagant that we citizens are asking for.

Seven Lucky Indian Citizens September 26, 2010

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, The world this week, West Bengal.
Tags: , ,
2 comments

The Government of India does not usually care for the deaths of its citizens.

There are a lucky few who do get the attention due to them even though they might be dead by then.

Last week there were actually seven of them for whose deaths two government departments got in to a war of words and one of them even expressed anguish!

Seven elephants were killed on a railway track in West Bengal due to collision with a goods train.

The minister of environment Jairam Ramesh shed some Lacoste (of Crocodile fame..) tears from a plush hotel room and took up the matter with the Ministry of Railways.

Mamata Banerjee (Works on weekends as Minister of Railways) actually expressed anguish for deaths! At last!

I heard Jairam Ramesh talk about the collision detectors and Railways talk about caution (a new word in their dictionary) in train operations.

I hope similar feelings will start flowing for dead human beings, who call India their home, from their “elected” representatives.

I want to hear Mamata Banerjee, at least once during my lifetime, express anguish for the deaths of human beings caused by the Railways rather than smelling conspiracy everytime.

This needs to happen soon otherwise Save the Tiger program has to be replaced by Save the Indian Citizen (Homo Sapiens) program.

State Elections – Terror Plank December 9, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, Democracy, Elections, India, Terrorism, The world this week.
Tags: , , , ,
add a comment

Yesterday the results of the state elections have been announced. Congress has not done as badly as it might have expected to do in the face of the intense scrutiny it’s government at the centre faced in the aftermath of the terror strikes in Mumbai.

This however should not goad Congress or BJP in to thinking that terrorism is not an important topic for the Indian electorate. Internal Security is the most important priority for the Indian state and the incumbent government should do all it can to ensure safety of the common man on the streets. It should not go slow on any of the implementations related to internal security that it might have been contemplating over the last two weeks.

We should embark on a continuos process to strengthen the loopholes in our security set up and ensure that we have impregnable borders with Pakistan and Bangladesh.

Mumbai Terror Attack: Time to introspect and take action December 7, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, India, Pakistan, Politics, Terrorism, The world this week.
Tags: , , , , , ,
add a comment

India should look inwards now. More than Pakistan the systemic failures of the numerous ministries and organizations in India is responsible for the disaster that was Mumbai on 26/11.

Internal Security should be given the same amount of policy space as economic growth during the first phase of economic liberlization. Radical changes are needed and nothing less than a “Green Revolution” in internal security set up will do.

We need to strengthen ourselves and come up to a level in internal security where we can call ourselves “civilzed”. [126 policemen per 100,000 people, policemen using arms which were last used by the Mughals, recruiting the least educated people in the police service and paying them peanuts are some of the things we need to correct ASAP. As per an article in India Today the city of New York has more than 50,000 CCTVs in public places including mosques and temples. The whole of India does not have the same number of CCTVs.]

In addition we need to continue to engage ourselves in mature diplomacy to force the hand of the state of Pakistan and Bangladesh against the rogue elements who call these nations their home and inflict damage on innocent people in the name of their warped sense of religious identity.

The media needs to help the country. Publishing sensational news items and bashing Pakistan is not helping us. A criminal will change his/her ways if he/she realizes the enormity of the crime that has been committed. However to the “third party actors” of Pakistan this is a “Holy” war. Nothing absolutely nothing is going to change them. Media needs to represent the people and work towards keeping the government on its toes and making it accountable to the people who voted it to power. It needs to act as a catalyst to expedite a change in the way our government deals with internal security. It needs to ensure that people retain their faith in democracy and it should also help us realize that we are responsible for the government we have and therefore change has to come from us in the form of votes.

Pakistan will NOT take action against LET December 7, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in India, Pakistan, Politics, Terrorism, The world this week.
Tags: , , , , , , , ,
2 comments

The news that is making the headlines from yesterday is that Pakistan has supposedly agreed to take action against some LET militants within a 48 hours timeline. I think that this news item is based on rumors.
Pakistan is not going to do anything at all. Especially not in the short term. Pakistan knows that India has very limited capability to take any action against them right away.I do not know why such news items are given any credence at all by our media. They should not give any importance to such rumors. Instead they should concentrate on publishing news items which will help make India stronger and keep the country united in times of such crisis.

Mumbai Terror Attack – Jingoism will not help India December 3, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, India, Pakistan, Politics, Terrorism, The world this week.
Tags: , , , , , , , ,
add a comment

I was hooked to the television last week when the terror strike was carried out in Mumbai. Like a lot of other people in our country and abroad I too felt extremely sad and depressed. On the day the last terrorist was killed I thought to myself that every unfortunate event has a silver lining and this event will surely act as a wake up call to our government and the sundry diplomatic and security establishments which function under it.

Today when I was watching the news in the afternoon I realized that my hopes were completely misplaced. The government of this country not only could not take precautionary measures but have also failed to come up with any plans to address the issue of terrorism in the aftermath of this strike. What is even more sad is that the government does not seem to have the political will to work in a constructive manner to resolve this crisis. All it has done till now seems to be with an eye to the next years general elections. Let me explain to you why I say so.

Terrorism can be rooted out of this country by taking the following measures. (I am sure there are a lot of other things that should be done however these are the ones I could think of with my limited understanding of the world around me.)

SHORT AND MEDIUM TERM MEASURES

1. Improving the implementation of the current anti-terror laws.

2. Ensuring that the existing internal security apparatus is proactive rather than re-active.

3. Leasing new life in to the already existing internal security forces and establishments which are for all purposes defunct due to lack of funds, material and personnel. The best example is the Indian Coast Guard and the Marine Police Units in most of the states.

4. Creating an elite federal anti-terror agency.

5. Getting in to public-private partnerships with corporates to ensure that our commercial establishments have adequate security cover and that the entire burden does not fall exclusively on the tax payers.

6. Create a Central Military Command to which all the service chiefs will report to.

7. Create a powerful coordinating agency which will ensure that ALL intelligence agencies talk to each other and the intelligence inputs received by sundry organizations at various levels are acted upon swiftly.

8. Raise a special force to protect the borders in the north eastern part of our country specially the porous borders we have with Nepal and Bangladesh.

LONG TERM MEASURES

1. Implement plans which will improve the economic conditions of the deprived sections of our society. Cosmetic measures like reservations and personal law boards are no good. Last 60 years have proved that. These cosmetic measures will only create ghettos which are poor,un-educated and vulnerable.

2. Take up special plans to improve the economic infrastructure in North East, Bihar, Chattisgarh, Jharkhand and Madhya Pradesh. This will root out terrorism and naxalism to a large extent.

PAKISTAN

It is high time that we realize that Pakistan is a reality that we have to engage with constructively. We cannot afford to fight another war against them. The civilian government in that country needs help and cooperation to ensure that it can defeat the forces which breed terrorists and unleash them on India. We have to fight a two pronged battle here. We need to provide clear proof to them about the involvement of their nationals in activities that are detrimental for us and at the same time we should provide the same proof to the international community so that diplomatic pressure can be built. Only when the military in Pakistan realize that their source of funds will completely dry out if they do not take counter measures against the rogue elements in their country will they mend their ways. This will also help the civilian government to exercise full pressure on them and to get some sort of control on them. A civilian government in Pakistan which is in absolute control over all the security institutions in that country is the best thing that can happen to India and the world.

What have we done till now:

1. Fire some non-performing ministers.
2. Make jingoistic remarks against Pakistan and ensure that they harden their stand. This has also ensured that the civilian government in Pakistan completely bows down to the hardline anti-India elements in that country.
3. Leak selective details of interrogation of the lone terrorist ONLY to the media without coming up with any authoritative document which can be provided to Pakistan,United Nations and the people of India as the full proof of the involvement of Pakistan based groups in this attack.
4. Give a list of 21 felons to Pakistan which they are not going to accept. That is their well known stand. Providing that list without providing documented proof of this attack being carried out by Pakistani nationals does not make any sense. Aren’t we being naive in thinking that this group will be deported to India now when Pakistan has rejected this multiple times in the past.

The government is trying to divert the attention of our people by creating a war like scenario with Pakistan. They think this will help them to fool people in to thinking that action has been taken in the aftermath of the attacks and will convert in to votes. They want to de-rail the peace process till the next elections and leave the task of picking up the pieces to the next government (Even if they themselves form it).

The incumbent government should ensure that we engage with Pakistan in this issue by creating diplomatic pressure. No one in the government and the media should be allowed to make irresponsible comments which increases the deep sense of hate and mistrust the two nations have towards each other. If India cannot force Pakistan diplomatically to close down the terror camps in Pakistan the flow of terrorists to India will not stop. Pressure from the international community especially USA and China can make that happen. Eye ball to Eye ball stand of our armies or a war will not achieve this objective.

Preview – The 2009 General Election Tamasha November 16, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, Politics, The world this week.
Tags: , ,
1 comment so far

The election season has finally arrived after five years in India. The arrival has been marked by jingoism about regional and religious identity.

The political class of India, which has always put the benefit of the country on a lower priority compared to their own and their party’s benefit, has started off the campaign with some really dirty tricks which is going to affect the future of this country very badly. The best part of this is that it is happening with the help of tax payer’s money. I think our politicians are the biggest frauds of all times. I am therefore not surprised that a few of my friends consider the terms “Politician” and “Police” as abuse.

A section is supporting Raj Thackerey’s mindless antics in the hope of getting the Marathi vote bank which has traditionally been Shiv Sena’s and the other section is supporting a group of alleged terrorists who blew six people to smithereens in the name of revenge.

I am sure no one will talk about the following topics in the coming months leading up to the elections because they are not “vote-winners” like caste, regionalism and religious intolerance. It is time that we citizens prove the assumptions of the political class wrong and demand answers to these issues:

– Inclusive Economic Growth (Eradication of poverty)
– Compulsory Primary Education (Plan for “industry relevant” higher education also needs some srious thinking)
– Food Security
– Energy Security
– Defence (Inspite of all the brouhaha the CAG has pointed out gaping holes in the Air and Naval defence capability of our country)
– Security of life and property against indiscriminate terrorist attacks.
– The problem of Bangladeshi migrants in Assam and West Bengal.
– Economic Growth plans for the North Eastern states. (When will our leaders show some action in this region. Till date the only thing people have seen or heard are empty promises).
– Naxal Problem.
– Plans to combat China’s eagerness to claim any strategically important territory in their neighbourhood as their own.
– Plans to engage our neighbouring countries. (Few of them are on their way to become failed states).

Just like the citizens of USA I am eagerly waiting for that day when change will finally arrive in this great nation.

The annual bomb blast festival May 15, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, The world this week.
Tags: , , ,
1 comment so far

The annual bomb blast festival of the anti-India terrorists have started off again for the 2008 season with Jaipur as the epicentre. The pink city is all pink and red with the blood of the victims.

The government of India too on its part has extended full support and cooperation to this by doing the following routine activities:

1. Blame Pakistan and Bangladesh. No action will be taken. Jingoistic statements will be made and at times totally irresponsible threats will be issued to these countries in front of the members of the print and electronic media.

2. Post blast investigation which will not lead to anything. Be rest assured that after about a month some individual will arrested from a distant corner of the country and will be blamed to be one of the master minds of the attacks who for some odd reason could not escape to either Pakistan or Bangladesh. The goverment will not overhaul the intelligence agencies, will not create separate organisations to deal with terrorism and naxals on a war footing.

3. Visits to the blast locations by leaders and thereby cause inconvenience to all and sundry. This is essential now because otherwise our home minister has no other way of showing that he exists. These leaders will not take any concrete steps to eradicate this problem of terrorism, will create regional economic imbalances so that terrorists can recruit the aliented people and will talk about “ZERO TOLERANCE”. Just ask our home minister what does he mean by that and I am sure his answers will be:

1. Repeal POTA: This is because it is very harsh on those terrorists and politicians who work for us during the election campaigns.

2. Stall the death sentence of terrorists belonging to “religious minorities” (A term coined by his party) so that my party can get sympathy votes during the elections next year.

Good resource for listening to the music of Mohiner Ghoraguli April 17, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Entertainment.
Tags: , ,
2 comments

This page in You Tube has a great collection of songs and videos of Mohiner Ghoraguli. Check them out.

If you have not heard about this group before given below is a brief introduction I found in Wikipedia.

Moheener Ghoraguli or Mohiner Ghoraguli (Bengali:translation: Moheen’s Horses) was a Bengali music group from Kolkata. It is difficult to classify them into a musical genre, as their music was a mixture of a wide variety of influences, including the Baul and folk traditions of Bangla and rock.

Established in the 1970s during a period of stagnation in Bangla music, when commercial film songs were the dominant market force, the lyrics (and to some extent the compositions) of leader Gautam Chattopadhyay were radically new. They were of a very personal or social nature, similar to the urban folk movement lead by Bob Dylan in the 60s. Though they were almost unknown in their time, in recent years they have undergone a critical re-evaluation much like the Velvet Underground. This can not be understood without a little background on the Jibonmukhi movement.

They are sometimes also credited as the pioneers of the flourishing of Bangla bands in the new millenium. However this is debatable as their songwriting was strongly rooted in Bangla folk and also American urban folk, while modern Bangla bands like Fossils are mostly influenced by the angst of grunge.

Their signature song is Prithibita Naki, a reflection on how television creates urban alienation. It has been covered by many artists.

Style

Moheener Ghoraguli (or Mohiner Ghoraguli) was formed by a group of Kolkata musicians led by Gautam Chattopadhyay towards the end of 1974. Initially, they called themselves ‘Saptarshi’, and after dilly-dallying with various names including ‘Teerandaz’, ‘Nogor Shongkeerton’ finally settled on the name ‘Moheener Ghoraguli’ proposed by Ranjon Ghoshal. The name was borrowed from a poem ‘Ghora’ by Jibanananda Das. Around the same time, other Bengali bands such as Souls and Feedback were forming across the border in Bangladesh.

The 1970s were not a propitious time for an experimental group like Moheener Ghoraguli. It was the heyday of classic Bengali singers such as Hemanta Mukhopadhyay, Sandhya Mukhopadhyay, Shyamal Mitra, etc – soloists who were responsible for creating the canon of adhunik gaan or ‘modern Bengali songs’. These were songs that updated the tradition of Tagore and Nazrul. They were traditional in their instruments and arrangements, and traditional in their themes and lyrics. They often appeared for the first time in the soundtrack of Bengali movies before getting wider release. Indeed, composers like Salil Chowdhury maintained a bank of their compositions, to use when they were requested to score a film. These were usually typical romantic songs, fluffy and unmemorable in their lyrical content. The situation has been compared to the mellow, commercial Tin Pan Alley music in USA that led to the rebellious rock’n’roll movement.

In such a conservative climate, Moheener Ghoraguli, with its unorthodox musical compositions and strange choice of song themes, failed to gain much of a fan base. Its songs dealt with everyday topics -politics, poverty, injustice, revolution, love, loneliness, even begging and prostitution. Gautam Chattopadhyay had strong political beliefs; in common with many intelligent and idealistic young men of his generation, he was involved in socialist/communist politics during the 1960s and 1970s. (According to former bandmate Abraham Mazumdar, Gautam may have been involved in the Naxalite movement as well.[citation needed]) This political outlook was reflected in the musical output of the band.

The type of music that Moheener Ghoraguli pioneered, though debatably, had the seeds of now very popular Jibonmukhi gaan or ‘Songs of ordinary life’. Two decades after Moheen, singers like Kabir Suman, Nochiketa and Anjan Dutta took Jibonmukhi gaan to a new level of popularity, but the origins of the genre can be found in the songs of Moheener Ghoraguli.

The band recorded with Western instruments and also experimented in a variety of musical styles, some of which must have jarred with the sensibilities of its audience. Today, these compositions sound quite contemporary, leading many to conclude that Moheener Ghoraguli was indeed ahead of its time. The band freely borrowed elements from baul shongeet, the folk music of rural Bengal . It can therefore lay claim to be the original Bengali folk-rock band. Many bands since Moheen have adopted similar innovations, among them Feedback, Dolchhut and Bangla.

The group played together till 1981 and was then dissolved. Its music too was largely forgotten. Then in the mid-1990s, a decade and a half after its dissolution, Gautam Chattopadhyay decided to revive Moheener Ghoraguli. The original members all had professional commitments now, so Gautam decided to put together a new lineup, composed mainly of young musicians.

The first album issued by the new-look Moheener Ghoraguli was a compilation called Abar Bochhor Kuri Porey (“Again, After Twenty Years”, a qutation from Jibonanondo Das), released at the Kolkata Book Fair. It included a number of original classics from the 1970s, as well as songs recorded by the new lineup. Although listeners were initially slow to catch on, the album proved to be a hit, and it introduced the band to a new generation of music-lovers. Gautam Chattopadhyay finally saw his music gain the popularity and critical recognition that had eluded his band in the 1970s. Several other successful compilations have followed since the first one. Both in their native West Bengal and in Bangladesh, Moheener Ghoraguli is now a much-admired band.

Gautam’s death in 1999 was sudden. After returning from a location shooting of his last film Rong Bin, which was never completed, the next day he went to the Indropuri studio to meet his longtime cinematographer friend and colleague, Vivek Banerjee and there he collapsed and died of a heart attack. An entire generation of budding musicians who had been popularized by Gautam in Kolkata mourned his untimely death and a tribute album “Moni chara shunno laage” (We feel empty without Moni) was released; it should be noted here that Moni was Gautam’s nickname.

Band members

Original lineup:

  • Gautam Chattopadhyay (Manik a.k.a. Moni-da to his younger siblings) – voice, lead guitar, saxophone, lyrics
  • Abraham Mazumdar – piano, violin
  • Pradip “Bula” Chattopadhyay – bass guitar, flute
  • Ranjon Ghoshal – lyrics, emcee, visuals, media relations
  • Biswanath “Bishu” Chattopadhyay – drums, bass violin
  • Tapas “Bapi” Das – voice, guitar
  • Tapesh “Bhanu” Bandopadhyay – voice, guitar (till 1978)

Later Members:

  • Raja Banerjee – Guitar (1978 onwards)

After Tapesh Bandopadhyay left the band in 1978, he was replaced by Raja Banerjee. Raja went on to record the third Moheen album Drishyomaan Moheener Ghoraguli with the band and performed in numerous concerts till the band was disbanded.

Caste based reservation in India – Back in focus April 13, 2008

Posted by prithweesh in Current Affairs, Politics, The world this week.
Tags: , , ,
add a comment

The Supreme Court of India has helped the Congress(I) to heave a sigh of relief by clearing the way to implement the bill related to caste based reservation in higher educational institutions. However how beneficial is reservation for the country is a question which is still a topic of debate.

I strongly disagree with the idea of reservation in professional educational courses and in research. I strongly feel that reservation should be limited to school education, general college education and general stream university courses. Moreover the whole process of reservation should have a fixed shelf life. We cannot go on with reservation for another 100 years. One generation should get the benefit.

Professional Courses like Medicine,Engineering,Law and Management should be outside the ambit of reservation. These courses produce professionals whose activities determine the fate of the nation and the safety and security of general populace depends on their calibre. These people should be the very best India has. For the very same reason I feel the admission to research institutions like IISC should also be solely on merit.

The polictical parties are bartering the future of our nation for their narrow political gains. The silent majority like us should start protesting against these moves and should use whatever avenues we have to ensure that the political parties get the message.

I only have one question for all the people who are votaries of reservation. Will you be comfortable in taking your children to a doctor knowing fully well that he/she gained admission to a medical school based on reservation and not on merit? (A majority of these students do not pass their courses in a single sitting.) [I am aware of many backward class students who do gain admission to IITs and IIMs based on merit and are some of the best professionals in their area of work.]